Friday, April 3, 2009

Why is bladder cancer underdiagnosed in women?

When bladder cancer is diagnosed in women, it's usually more advanced than when it's diagnosed in men. As a result, browsing around and reading about it, you get the impression that bladder cancer diagnosis in women is a much more dangerous thing than in men.

Bladder cancer is also more common in men than in women, but the gap is narrowing - it's believed that this is because smoking is a major contributor to cancer and women are smoking at a higher rate than in the past - closer to the rate men smoke. Well, that may be true in Asia or Europe, but in the US it seems all smoking is dropping so much, I'm not sure I can name a single woman I know who smokes!

But still, reading statistical summaries about survivability and whatnot, it doesn't seem to look as good for women as men. Apparently, the five year survival rate for women is equal to ten year survival rate for men.

That scared me at first. But then reading more about and thinking more about it, it seems to me that there are a few things going on.

First of all, no offense to men - they are kind of wimps. A little burning when they pee and some of them think their you-know-what will fall off and they run to the doctor. Since men tend not to go to doctors as much as women, when they do they are taken more seriously.

Second of all, women are much more prone than men to get urinary tract infections. Something about our biology and short urethras. So coming in with complaints like burning and blood in the urine frequently gets a woman an antibiotics prescription and since these symptoms tend to come and go (when they are caused by BC) they'll clear up and everything thinks it's all fine.

Third of all, blood in the urine is frequently dismissed as a symptom in women (both by doctors and by the women themselves) as it's assumed that maybe it's menstrual blood traces and some techs must have thought I was stupid as they've asked me if I recently had my period after they found blood in my urine and after I told them "not even close" still assumed that the right thing to do was to just ask me to come back and retest in a week. Since the hematuria is usually intermittent the symptom goes away before next time and the diagnosis isn't made.

So as a result, by the time the right diagnosis is reached, it might be a man's first complaint about a symptom and a woman's tenth in who-knows-how-many years. So he's early stage, and she's advanced stage.

I'm glad my primary doctor insisted on referring me to a urologist and badgered me into going within days after they decided my "infection" seemed to be something abnormal. I'm glad that I went to a urologist who insisted on doing a cystoscopy even after a clean CT and ultrasound - the initial suspicion was kidney stones, but those didn't show up.

I'm still a bit worried about the persistent UTI I had summer of '07 which didn't result in a referral to anywhere just a bunch of antibiotics. I'm thinking that might have been back when this started, but who knows. The urologist did tell me I could have had these tumors for years and not known it, as it's not really known how fast they grow - it probably varies by individual.

Here's a good webpage with a summary of these issues for women plus some cool stories from women who've had bladder cancer.

And here's another sobering statistic about bladder cancer, which has been considered the cancer of old white men till recently:

Women with bladder cancer - 143,000
Women with ovarian cancer - 162,000
Women with cervical cancer - 189,000

I don't know about you, but I was shocked to see these numbers - I've heard so much more about risk of ovarian and cervical cancer than bladder cancer - all those urges to get annual pap smears hoping to catch cervical cancer early... and then we go and ignore symptoms which strongly suggest being tested for bladder cancer.

So, there's a good chance I'm now going to turn into one of those annoying people - when I hear a woman complain about a persistent UTI that just won't go away, I'm going to tell her to go get screened for bladder cancer. I hope she doesn't freak out or think I'm a silly worry wart, and tells me in her best Ahnold Schwarzenegger imitation "It's not a toomah" and then goes to a urologist and gets it confirmed.

While digging around in statistical research, which I'll be the first to admit I'm woefully poorly equipped to understand fully due to getting a D in my statistical analysis class in college, I did discover this table:

5 year relative survival rates for 1996-2002 (the numbers get higher with the more recent years)

By stage (at diagnosis)


Total Men Women

Localized 94.2 95.0 91.8

Regional 46.8 48.8 41.5


By age (at diagnosis)
__-45 91.3 91.1 91.9
45-54 86.9 87.4 85.1
55-64 86.5 87.2 83.8
65-74 82.6 83.7 78.8
75- 74.0 76.9 67.3



Full tables are here.

So, looks like the younger women have narrowed the gap. In fact, the gender gap which widened through the 70's and 80's started narrowing in the 90's again. Not sure if this is just a side effect of the error margin, my own misinterpretation of what these mean or what, or that women are opting for more aggressive treatment like men, or they are not being misdiagnosed as much as in the past.

So what does this all mean for me? Absolutely nothing. I am not a statistic, though I do plan to make decisions based on the latest available research and I plan to get the most aggressive appropriate treatment for me based on my situation. And if needed, I'll get a third and fourth opinions too.

Damn pushy females, who do they think they are - men?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Is the diagnosis age the initial diagnosis on the survival rate chart? I ask because of the rate of recurrence. It could be that with each recurrence the chance of the cancer being more aggressive increases and it would seem logical that as one gets older one is more likely to have a recurrence. So if each recurrence is treated as a diagnosis, then it could influence the data.

Asya said...

I believe it refers to initial diagnosis. I actually would think that recurrences would be less dangerous as someone previous treated for this would be under very close monitoring - I've been told I'll be going in for follow-ups every three months for the first two years.

Of course, hopefully the technology will improve so that monitoring will some day become as easy as a dipstick test...

Mark said...

If we're going to get all gender-ish on this topic, I'm trying to figure out that line about men running to the doctor when they have a little burning while they pee. First of all, isn't that what we're supposed to do? Why preface it by calling us wimps (even if we are)? More to the point, isn't that actually a backhanded swipe at doctors for taking men with that symptom more seriously? Aren't you saying doctors are sexist? Or at least, there are more male doctors, and they tend to be more sexist? So the statistical analysis is flawed because of the ratio of male to female diagnositicians?

Asya said...

Statistical analysis can't be flawed, it is what it is. Why it is the way it is - well, unfortunately sexist doctors is as plausible a theory as any...